Monje, Jose Claro N.

Ateneo de Manila · 27 comments

3.4

based on 27 comments

positive 8
neutral 19
mixed 0
negative 0

Clarity3.0

Workload3.7

neutral

Van Caparas Hello! Any tips for the orals?

neutral

sir bartilet, crammed a sems worth of reqs inn3 days and straight up didnt take my midterm orals (HE flaked during my makeup..), and managed to get a B+ GWHEHWJAHmore

neutral

Bartilet!! unli cuts just do well on orals, barely went to class and still got an a

positive

Bartilet if u want a philo that's barely there. Easy A and super nice but pls do not to abuse it.

neutral

I would never suggest Mariano to anyone for mental health sake. Just search and you can already see different reviews about him. Laetitia Nicole Franco for more referencemore

neutral

life changing dahil sa inis si sir mariano eme HAHAHAHAHAHA

positive

Si Bartilet kasi di life-changing pero free A, si Mariano life-changing pero hard B+ so pili ka nalang ng magpapa-“worth it” ng tuition mo.

neutral

Anonymous member 169 For context, i missed my midterm orals due to sickness so he scheduled a makeup online one. well i waited for 45 mins and he never showed up GWHEHHD and never replied whne i asked abt itmore

positive1 reaction

mariano changed me… in ways i cannot explain… taking his class messed up my mental health… i’d say take him for funsies (kase funny nmn sha minsan) but if you cannot afford the anxiety and the stress, don’t. ang lala bes! 😭more

neutral1 reaction

Kim Veranga tapos walang nakuha in terms of ethics lessons

positive

I took Sir Bartilet for two Philo subjects and I'd do it again if I had the chance tbh. I believe he did recits the second time around, but I wouldn't worry about it at all cuz he's definitely on the chiller side of profs. It's easy to get distracted during class especially if pagod ka na from the day and evening yung class niya, but do your best to take notes! He teaches in Filipino, but he's very kind during recits if you're not too fluent. He will even point out sometimes how uve improved speaking hehehe. Best tip I could give you is DO WELL IN ORALS (which is relatively chill din imo)more

positive

Enlo Took him for 11.04 last SY first sem! Here are ma tots: Pros - workload is doable; mostly cornell notes (organized way of taking down notes from readings), then for the essay assessments, you’ll need to explain the given texts using both readings and personal example (well thats what i did lol), there’s midterm and final orals but our midterm was recorded for some reason I forgot I think some students reached out to him. - very considerate w deadlines. I remember he extended the cornell notes multiple times and even accepted late submissions (pls dont abuse his kindness lawl hahaha). - sometimes he dismisses early din hahaha 👨🏻‍🍼 - very chill prof literally hahah; never saw him mad tbh which is kinda scary lawl, very tatay vibes and yeah there will be times where you’ll get bored during his discussion because the way he speaks is so reserved and slow placed. Also, in terms of teaching style — he seems to only go by the book and use the examples from there, which i didnt mind tbh it helped naman hahah. - grades high afaik; i remember getting all As for my cornell notes when he released it at the last week of the sem lol. - the only con i remember is that he cancels class like minutes before the class time so since my class were in the late afternoon, I wasted some days going to school for nothing hahahha (He has a lot of fam emergencies ;-;) Vv A-able would retake his class if given the chance :>more

positivePHILO 13

Copy-pasted: Hi I took Mr. Bartilet for PHILO 13, AY 2023–2024 S2. 1. Requirements (actual, not the ones on syllabus* - refer to 3d for details) a. Several Cornell notes b. Several ethical case studies c. Report about one reading d. Midterm and final oral exam (our final oral exam became recorded for some reason) 2. Pros a. Everything is done in groups of 3 except the midterm and final oral exam (idk if that’s a pro or con, but pro for me kasi may friends ako sa class). - Even though there are a lot of requirements in terms of number, the Cornell notes are pretty easy to make naman. - Yung ethical cases may guide naman siyang binigay. - Yung report about one reading was done toward the end of the semester, so pwede mong i-reference yung Cornell notes. - Generally yung kailangan mo lang i-review would be the orals. He gives the thesis statements in advance. I got a thesis statement na wala sa kahit anong reading which is very weird but the other three statements in the midterm and all four statements in the final were in the reading naman. Disclaimer: Whether or not we did it correctly, hindi na namin alam kasi wala nga siyang binalik. b. I think he doesn’t care if you… - Cut (refer to 3b for the reason). Though hindi ko sure if he cares if you’re late, kasi wala akong nakikitang nale-late. Either on time or di na talaga nag-aattend. - Do other requirements in class c. Naka-A ako sa kanya. So yes at least after that whole sem of no feedback, at least I guess it was fine. If you want a chill class and ez A, just take the PHILO 13 Filipino class at night (kasi the dept is probably gonna gatekeep the profs from the students). 3. Cons a. It’s as if hindi siya nagtuturo sa Ateneo. Parang may sinusunod siyang sariling calendar. - He sends us announcements via the OBF email kahit na na-inform na siya ng beadle - He didn’t know about the university holiday on Jan 25. - One of our tasks had English instruction (the class is Filipino), and we were asked to submit it to the class president (“president” sabi niya, hindi “beadle”). - May sarili siyang digital day na different from the university’s. - Kahit na study day may online class pa kami. b. Marami siyang async class, tapos mostly ina-announce on the same day (hapon pa). For context, 5pm yung class namin, tapos may time na nag-send siya at 4:47pm (13 minutes before the class). - Marami siyang mga emergency sa buhay. Hindi ko alam if I will still believe him. He got sick a few times, may family emergency a couple times, may emergency meeting, tapos nasunugan din yung bahay kaya late na-release yung grades namin. Whenever that happens, sasabihin lang niyang async yung class and ire-remind kami to do our readings and other activities - The midterm orals of half the class dapat nasa isang Monday, pero bigla-bigla na lang siya nag-message one night before na mamu-move sa Thursday of that same week. c. His onsite classes, which are already very few to start with, are very unproductive. - There were several times that he would just ask students to read aloud the reading. Parang grade school vibes. - Nagpapacomment siya about the reading, pero medyo insubstantial; doesn’t add depth to either the reading or the students’ points. d. His syllabus was released late (week 4 na lumabas) and he didn’t really follow its contents, especially regarding requirements. e. He takes a very long time to reply to emails. - This is quite ironic, since many of his emails end with “Kung may mga katanungan ay huwag kayong mahihiyang mag-email”. - He has also not returned the grades of any single requirement back.more

neutral2 reactions

Anonymous member 887 I was beadle for his class (pinili ako, i know i have the choice to say no, nahihiya p ako mag say ng no) anyway, he doesn't return grades, doesn't post submission portals on time, comes to class late also, doesn't reply to inquiry emails (fr, the first and only reply i got from him was during finals when i sent him the final orals sched) In class, marami ka naman matutunan yataaa because most of the time he gets off topic and then circle back to his lesson. Plus most of the time he would repeat what he taught last meeting or last week tapos magiging late na kayo sa lesson plan then proceeds to speed things up when finals is near. His attitude can be pretty much seen in how he conducts himself in class, although maayos naman yung lecture at times, nakakaoverthink at nakakakaba yung kada patak ng oras ng walang binibigay na feedback about your performance sa midterm orals.more

Monje, Jose Claro N.

What students said

Breakdown

Comments

Teaching this term